A look at why and whether prison works as an answer to all serious crimes

Let the punishment fit the crime?

A look at why and whether prison works as an answer to all serious crimes

Theft crimes, for example, rise and fall with unemployment, but that's only one of many factors. Trouble sometimes begins with birth into environments of physical, sexual, or substance abuse, criminal activity, divorce, head injuries, poverty and ignorance.

But none of those precursors causes crime. Most people with those disadvantages do not become criminals.


Criminals also come from the better side of the tracks. In his book Inside the Criminal Mind, Dr. Samenow, a clinical psychologist, powerfully demolishes much of the conventional wisdom portraying criminals as victims of their parents, poverty, mental illnesses and life circumstances.

Samenow found that criminals are defined by how they think; and they definitely think differently than law-abiding people. Most criminals are manipulative, use people as they please, fancy themselves in control, con others successfully, posture as tough guys and do not like to work hard at school or regular jobs.

They thrive on intimidation and stealth.

All Crimes Are Equal - TV Tropes

Crooks dish it out, but cannot take criticism. A minority pity their victims.

A look at why and whether prison works as an answer to all serious crimes

Most have little remorse until caught. Crime progresses when these profoundly selfish young people bully others, get high, sell drugs, steal, gamble, rob stores, join gangs, rape and participate in violence, thrill seeking, intimidation and depravity.

Drugs, intoxicants, theft, gangs, sex, violence or some combination of them help create new age slaves. People decide to disobey the law for their own self-centered reasons.

Prisons are supposed to act as a deterrent to criminal activity. Being unpleasant, potential offenders should be so afraid of going to prison that they do not commit crimes. But it doesn't work that way. That's how law-abiding citizens think. The criminal mind works differently, with less foresight and conscience.

Criminals enjoy the excitement and risks, do not anticipate capture, and instead focus on what they want. By one computation, only 1.

Is prison the best punishment for all offenders? ? | Yahoo Answers

A low risk of punishment increases crime. Successful burglars celebrate their accomplishments. Good deterrents are certain, severe and swift. Prison is not certain, probation or youthful offender status often being granted or crimes are not even prosecuted.

Prison is not always perceived as severe. Many never see a prison until they arrive. Inmates often sleep or just sit in their cells.

When Mike Tyson first went to juvenile detention, it was like a reunion for him, because so many of his friends and acquaintances were already there - of course he was one of the few who did not worry about being attacked.In more complex criminal cases, such as those involving serious felonies, the sentencing judge usually receives input from the prosecutor, the defense, and the probation department (which prepares recommendations in a "pre-sentence report").

Aug 18,  · Best Answer: I defend prisoners for in prison crimes at Salinas Valley State Prison and Soledad State Prison.

Report Abuse

Both of these facilities are in California. SVSP is a level 4 prison, the highest security, and Soledad is a partial 2/3 facility with a level 1 fire Status: Resolved.

Skip to 1 minute and 30 seconds And also, when you look at particular crimes in society, such as violence against women, then arguably the prison doesn't necessarily incapacitate all of the dangerous people, all of the time.

So therefore you come back to the question of, well, what is the prison for? How the UK’s prison population has grown. The UK’s prison population has thus increased by an average rate of % per year since As the situation currently stands, England and Wales’s incarceration rate is people per , - compared to 98 in France, 82 in the Netherlands and 79 in Germany.

Here is an answer from a person who has been in prison. This is a complex question. People who have committed atrocities and serious crimes are mentally ill. They belong in asylums where they are separated from regular people and can get therapy.

A look at why and whether prison works as an answer to all serious crimes

But that does not account for most of the prison population or even 80% of them. A crime is a crime, regardless of whether it's committed in or out of prison, and a person committing it is subject to the same punishments regardless. In American prisons most crimes committed by prisoners aren't prosecuted legally.

Classification of Crimes | Criminal Law